hay - something exists

hay never changes form: no hayo, no hayes, always the same word. You use it when something is mentioned for the first time or stays unidentified: Hay un banco cerca. (There's a bank nearby - some bank.) Hay dos sillas en la cocina. (There are two chairs in the kitchen.)

After hay you usually find un/una/unos/unas, a number, or no at all - but never the definite el/la/los/las: Hay agua en la botella. (There's water in the bottle - no , because water here is uncountable.)

estar - where is something?

estar gives the location of a specific, already-known thing. That's why it's usually preceded by the definite , a possessive, or a name: El banco está cerca. (This particular, specific bank is nearby.) La mesa está al lado de la ventana. (The table - a specific one - is next to the window.)

estar is conjugated as usual; for talking about where things are, you mainly need está (he/she/it/you formal) here.

The switch: first hay, then estar

You often mention something with hay first and then describe it with estar - by then it's already known: Hay un supermercado cerca. Está al lado de la farmacia. (There's a supermarket nearby. It's next to the pharmacy.) This switch is exactly the core of the difference.

Questions work the same way: ¿Hay un supermercado cerca? asks whether one even exists. ¿Dónde está el supermercado? asks for the location of an already-known, specific supermarket.

Examples

  • Hay un banco cerca.
  • El banco está cerca.
  • Hay una mesa en la cocina.
  • La mesa está al lado de la ventana.
  • ¿Hay un supermercado cerca? Sí, hay uno.
  • ¿Dónde está el supermercado? Está al lado de la farmacia.

Exercises

A1Grammarhay and estar for location

Exercise 1 of 6

hay or está?

Sort each sentence under the matching function.

Which word is missing: is this about existence or the location of a specific thing?

___ un banco cerca.
El banco ___ cerca.
___ una mesa en la cocina.
La mesa ___ al lado de la ventana.
___ dos sillas en la cocina.
La silla ___ al lado de la puerta.

hay

está

A1Grammarhay and estar for location

Exercise 2 of 6

hay or está in a sentence

Choose the right word for each sentence.

un supermercado cerca de mi casa.
El supermercado al lado de la farmacia.
En la cocina una mesa.
La mesa al lado de la ventana.

You now know the basic rule. Next you'll see hay and está again in real questions and answers - just like in everyday life, when you ask about something or explain where it is.

A1Grammarhay and estar for location

Exercise 3 of 6

¿Hay...? or ¿Dónde está...?

Match each question with the fitting answer.

Which answer fits which question?

A1Grammarhay and estar for location

Exercise 4 of 6

hay and está in a short text

Choose the right word throughout the whole text.

En mi piso dos dormitorios.
Mi dormitorio al lado de la cocina.
En mi dormitorio una cama y un armario.
La cama al lado de la ventana.

Now for the most important step: the switch from hay to está itself. You'll get only a sentence with hay - turn it into a sentence with está, with no options to choose from.

A1Grammarhay and estar for location

Exercise 5 of 6

Now with está

Now use está to say exactly where this one thing is.

Hay un banco cerca.

Finally, it works the other way round: the mistake between hay and está is already in the sentence. Can you find it and correct it?

A1Grammarhay and estar for location

Exercise 6 of 6

Is the sentence correct?

Correct the sentence.

Hay mi libro en la mesa.